deviant art

Deviant Login Shop
 Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour
[x]
more ▶

More from ^Katara-Alchemist in News

Featured in Groups:

Details

July 13, 2012
Link
Thumb

Statistics

Comments: 16
Favourites: 10 [who?]

Views: 1,166 (0 today)
[x]

Around the Site Suggestions: Volume 4

Fri Jul 13, 2012, 11:33 PM


Around the Site Suggestions: Volume 3

:iconhappywaveplz: Welcome to Around the Site Suggestions! This article will be published every other week and it will feature different suggestions from around the site. Suggestions will be taken from the visual suggestions gallery, the written suggestions gallery , the suggestions forum, the weekly site updates from #hq and anywhere else suggestions are posted. As well as featuring these suggestions, this article will also contain different discussion topics about different aspects of the site and how you would like to see them improved.

If you have a suggestion you would like featured in this article feel free to note me, ^Katara-Alchemist, with your suggestion and I'll include it in the next article! It doesn't even have to be yours, it can just be a cool one that you've see while browsing the site. Feel free to note me with suggestions for the discussion topic at the end as well.

Guide to Creating Suggestions

I recently put together a guide to creating suggestions, both visual and written! The guide covers:
:bulletblue:What is a deviantART related suggestion?
:bulletblue:What types of suggestions are there?
:bulletblue:Where can I make a suggestion?
:bulletblue:What should I consider when making a suggestion?
:bulletblue:How do I make a visual suggestion?
:bulletblue:How do I make a written suggestion?
:bulletblue:What are some examples of good suggestions?
:bulletblue:How can I get recognition for my suggestions?

You can read the full guide here: [link]

Suggestions From the Site Updates

*raberbagirl suggested "I'd like to be able to edit my older literature Deviations with Sta.sh files.

My older stories lost all their formatting (such as italics, which are really important) because it took too long to replace it all manually with html tags, but if I could upload the stories to Sta.sh, which preserves italics, and then replace the original story Deviation with that properly italicized file, it would help very much.

I really don't want to lose comments or flood my watchers by having to delete old Deviations and upload new ones from Sta.sh as if they were new, when they're really not."

__________


*16thSquadSanseki suggested "I just wanted to note one thing. If you add a topic in Group's Private Forum, it is in the message center but it doesn't increase Group Messages count. It would be nice if that could be changed, so other admins would know when there's a new note."
__________


=Ms-CoffeePixie suggested "I feel like if there was a 'Delete' option on the Manage Deviations page I would be really happy.
I'm the sort of person who will bulk clean out my gallery sometimes and it takes quite a long time having to go to each page one by one and click delete. I don't think I am the only one who would appreciate a feature like that."

__________


=mapal suggested "I still think a more dynamic way of selecting the used resources is a better idea >.> like people are going to bothered to search for the resource again and get the thumb link. Maybe, if you could, include a "select from your favourites" option so people can just fav things, then credit them."

From the Suggestions Forum

*JazzLizard Suggested more options for managing comments

~NinthTale Suggested a"Remove Deviation From Messages" button for films.

*LadyLuck89 Suggested we be able to store old journals in the same way we can store deviations.

From the Visual Suggestions gallery

:thumb307640824: =Strawboo suggested a "see results" button for polls.
=singularwish suggested changes to the statistics page.
`joannastar suggested updates to the suggestions gallery that would make it easier to see how popular certain suggestions are.

From the Written Suggestions Gallery

My 4 most wanted improvements to Deviantart.1. Provide fields for a description (and any number of links) for each person you're watching, so this info can be displayed in our message center.
When watching someone, let us be able to write private note about that user. (such as how we found out about them or how we met them, or what we like about their work, or what kind of art they make. It doesn't matter, the point is we can write literally anything there.) There should also be fields included for us to type in the urls to their other website(s), blog(s), tumblr(s), and pages on other art sites. If that user filled out any websites, then those could be added automatically, but we should still be able to add our own. These links, and whatever we wrote in the description field, should be displayed along with the user's name/icon in our message center. Aside from this making it infinitely easier to remember who literally every single person you're watching is, and making it easier keep tabs on their other sites (and so you
~anti-tanX suggested multiple ideas including being able to have saved descriptions of the people we watch and the ability to have artists stacks include their journals as well/

Suggestions From Elsewhere on the Site

None this time!

Discuss

This time we're going to discuss suggestions in general! When it comes to posting suggestions we currently have the option of the main suggestions forum, a couple staff personal forums, the two galleries, and the weekly site updates. Do you guys think there should be a more unified system, or should things be left as they are?

Discuss!

Thanks for reading!

Previous issues: #001 #002  #003


Add a Comment:
 
:iconanti-tanx:
I am surprised that there would be both a suggestions forum and a suggestions gallery.
Reply
:iconkatara-alchemist:
^Katara-Alchemist Jul 18, 2012  Student General Artist
May I ask why? Just out of curiosity.
Reply
:iconanti-tanx:
It isn't redundant to have both?

Well a gallery is good for visual suggestions and mockups.
It's only a written suggestion gallery that is redundant.
But then again if there's a visual suggestion gallery, why not a written suggestion gallery. No reason not to have both.
Plus the forum deletes topics a week old. So if you made a brilliantly worded suggestion, it is gone in a week. :p
Reply
:iconkatara-alchemist:
^Katara-Alchemist Jul 18, 2012  Student General Artist
I agree that the written suggestions gallery is rather pointless, not only because there's the written suggestions forum, but because it is FULL of miscats and there is hardly anything that actually belongs there.

The forum doesn't delete any topic unless it's spam, as far as I know. If things don't get replied to, they get pushed off the first page, but as long as they're being replied to they stay open and on the front page.
Reply
:iconsingingflames:
=SingingFlames Jul 14, 2012  Hobbyist Writer
I really like 'See Poll Results' suggestion, and the button to support suggestions. There's some other great ideas here too. :)

As for posting suggestions, I made the suggestion on the Site Update two weeks ago, that there should be a link to the Site Update, or to another topic for suggestions, across the bottom of the deviantArt page (with the Journal Portal, Poll, etc.). It's easy for people to delete the update or simply overlook it. If it's on every dA screen, it'll be more visible and easier for people to make suggestions. Some deviants don't visit the forums, or know about the Suggestion Galleries. I think it would be helpful to condense the options for suggestions. They seem a little scattered right now.
Reply
:iconkatara-alchemist:
^Katara-Alchemist Jul 14, 2012  Student General Artist
:nod: They are kind of scattered.
Reply
:iconms-coffeepixie:
=Ms-CoffeePixie Jul 14, 2012  Student Digital Artist
Thank you for featuring my suggestion! Hopefully DeviantART staff will take some of these great suggestions into consideration.
Reply
:iconkatara-alchemist:
^Katara-Alchemist Jul 14, 2012  Student General Artist
:nod: Hopefully! And you're welcome.
Reply
:iconladygagz:
I think suggestions should be more unified. :nod:

Here's what I would do if it were up to me:

:bulletblue: The staff's personal forums about suggestions should just be sticky forums in the suggestions forum.

:bulletblue: The Written Suggestion gallery should be scrapped and be replaced by the Suggestions forum. The Written Suggestions gallery isn't used a lot and I think like 90% of submissions in there are miscats anyway.

And I don't mind that the Site Updates are a place for suggestions.
Reply
:iconkatara-alchemist:
^Katara-Alchemist Jul 13, 2012  Student General Artist
I definitely agree with the bullets. The poor written suggestions gallery is horrendous.

:nod: The one thing I don't like as much about the site updates for suggestions is that it's harder for other deviants to see the ideas posted there and show their support.
Reply
Add a Comment: